Insuring your car is very important, especially in a city known for its traffic like Jefferson. However, you would want to explore a cheap insurance policy to cover your car in case of an auto crash or theft. Many insurance companies use a wide range of factors to determine the cost of auto insurance, including your address, age, type of car, and driving history.
To make an informed decision, we will highlight the average full coverage rates of auto insurance in Jefferson, Ohio. We will also analyze rates for both genders for all ZIP codes in Jefferson.
Average Cost of Car Insurance in Jefferson, Ohio
The average cost of auto insurance in Jefferson differs due to many factors. For instance, the number of accidents, the type of roads, and even the weather can affect the rates drivers are charged. In Jefferson, the average cost of car insurance is between $2,597-$2,700 for full coverage.
Cheapest Car Insurance Companies in Jefferson 2025
Before opting for car insurance, you need to search for an affordable and reliable company to insure your vehicle. There are a number of insurance companies in Jefferson that offer the best insurance rates.
1. Dona Norris: Allstate Insurance
Dona Norris: Allstate Insurance is an independent insurance agency that provides everything for customers ranging from home to auto to farm insurance. You can reach The General’s customer service phone number: +1 440-576-0343.
2. Glazier Insurance
The Glazier Insurance Agency, Inc. in Northeast Ohio is a full service, independent, insurance agency writing all lines of insurance including business, auto, home, health, both individual and group, and life insurance. The agency was eventually purchased by Everett H. Glazier in 1936 and he changed the name to the Glazier Insurance Agency.
3. Huntington Insurance
Huntington Bancshares Incorporated is a $179 billion asset regional bank holding company headquartered in Columbus, Ohio. Founded in 1866, The Huntington National Bank and its affiliates provide consumers, small and middle-market businesses, corporations, municipalities, and other organizations with a comprehensive suite of banking, payments, wealth management, and risk management products and services.
4. Treen Insurance Services
Treen Insurance Services is independently owned and locally operated to handle your insurance needs. We focus on customer service and offer affordable and reliable insurance choices all over Ohio and many surrounding states.
5. Darren M. Ryan Agency Inc American Family Insurance
Darren M. Ryan Agency Inc American Family Insurance is an Independent Insurance Agency with over 20 years of experience in the industry. We provide unique solutions to your insurance needs by offering the right coverage with the personal touch you would expect from your neighborhood insurance agent.
6. Sposito Insurance Agency Inc.
Sposito Insurance Agency Inc. has been serving Ashtabula County since 1971. We currently have offices in Ashtabula and Mentor OH. As a full-service insurance agency, our top priority is doing what is best for you. That means giving you the best coverage we can at the best price available. Our experienced staff will help you no matter what the situation. From sales to claims, we will help you every step of the way.
7. Allstate Insurance Agent: Kristen Daubenspeck Barger
Allstate Insurance Agent: Kristen Daubenspeck Barger is an independent agency serving clients in Ohio. The agency offers prompt, professional service for auto, home, life, and business insurance coverage to its customers’ needs. We’re a part of the local community. Get in touch with our friendly staff today!
8. Richmond & Richmond Insurance
Richmond & Richmond Insurance has been offering quality and cheap insurance services. They are niched as an all-inclusive insurance brokerage firm, dedicated to serving all the diverse insurance needs of Ohio individuals, families, and businesses.
9. Greenwood Insurance Agency Inc
For over 60 years the Greenwood Family has been giving families, individuals and businesses, across Ohio, peace of mind with fair and honest insurance consultation. It is an independent insurance company.
10. Humphrey Insurance Agency
Originally established in 1935 by Ralph L. Humphrey and later by his son, we’ve been committed to working up to the highest standards to provide Ashtabula, OH, and beyond with top-quality insurance and friendly, personalized service.
