Insuring your car is very important, especially in a city known for its traffic like Mahoning. However, you would want to explore a cheap insurance policy to cover your car in case of an auto crash or theft. Many insurance companies use a wide range of factors to determine the cost of auto insurance, including your address, age, type of car, and driving history.
To make an informed decision, we will highlight the average full coverage rates of auto insurance in Mahoning, Ohio. We will also analyze rates for both genders for all ZIP codes in Mahoning.
Average Cost of Car Insurance in Mahoning, Ohio
The average cost of auto insurance in Mahoning differs due to many factors. For instance, the number of accidents, the type of roads, and even the weather can affect the rates drivers are charged. In Mahoning, the average cost of car insurance is between $2,597-$2,700 for full coverage.
Cheapest Car Insurance Companies in Mahoning 2025
Before opting for car insurance, you need to search for an affordable and reliable company to insure your vehicle. There are a number of insurance companies in Mahoning that offer the best insurance rates.
1. General Insurance Agency
General Insurance Agency is an all-state insurance brokerage situated in Mahoning, Ohio. The company offers exceptional car insurance services at a cheaper rate anytime, any day. The company can be reached at; +1 330-793-3929.
2. Keystar Insurance LLC
Keystar Insurance LLC is one of the leading insurance brokerages in Ohio, United States. The company offers the best insurance services ranging from auto, health, life, security, etc. You can reach customer service via the company’s phone number; +1 330-423-0220.
3. Hearthstone Insurance Group LLC
Hearthstone Insurance Group LLC has been offering quality and cheap insurance services. They are niched as an all-inclusive insurance brokerage firm, dedicated to serving all the diverse insurance needs of Ohio individuals, families, and businesses.
4. Stonybrook Insurance
Stonybrook Insurance is an Ohio-based insurance company that focuses on specialty personal auto and car insurance. The company can be reached at; +1 330-286-3222.
5. Ashton Insurance Inc.
6. Ruddy Insurance Group
Shawn Ruddy envisioned Ruddy Insurance Agency seven years ago after graduating from Youngstown State University and giving two years of his life to Hubbard Township and Cortland Police Department as a policeman. He is every bit involved with and concerned about the needs of the community in which he was reared, which is why Shawn and Ruddy Insurance Group contribute to Toys for Tots as well as the local children’s hospital.
7. Uptown Insurance Agency
Uptown Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agency located in the historic Bayne Building, at 349 State Street, across from US Bank in Salem. The company can be reached at; +1 330-782-1199.
8. The Agent Insurance Services
The Agent Insurance Services – As a 5-star rated independent insurance agency, The Agent Insurance Services has locations in Boardman and Salem, Ohio. The company can be reached at; +1 330-758-3339
9. Champion Insurance of Austintown
CIA is an independent insurance agency, founded in 1999, representing many insurance companies. With over 50 years of experience, we provide our customers with quality products at competitive prices.
10. Mark Cole Agency
Mark Cole Agency has been offering quality and cheap insurance services. They are niched as an all-inclusive insurance brokerage firm, dedicated to serving all the diverse insurance needs of Ohio individuals, families, and businesses.
