Are you looking for the best insurance companies in Mahoning, Ohio? Well, there are numerous insurance companies in Mahoning, Ohio. However, before you settle for one, you need to shop around and compare quotes from multiple companies.
There are so many factors that insurers use to determine the cost of your insurance. Some of these factors include the type of insurance e.g auto, health, travel, property, etc., and your age, among others. That’s why you need to search for the best and cheapest insurance companies in Mahoning before making a choice.
To aid you in making the right choice, we have compiled the list of the cheapest and best insurance companies in Mahoning.
10 Best Insurance Companies in Mahoning, Ohio 2025
Below is the list of the best insurance companies in Mahoning, Ohio.
1. Keystar Insurance LLC
Keystar Insurance LLC was established in Ohio. The ERIE agency offers auto, home, commercial, and life insurance. Erie Insurance sells auto, home, life, and business insurance through a network of independent agents in 12 states and the District of Ohio.
2. Hearthstone Insurance Group LLC
Hearthstone Insurance Group LLC is one of the best insurance companies in Ohio. In addition, the company also offers home insurance, auto insurance, life insurance, and more. You can reach The General’s customer service phone number here: +1 330-423-6423.
3. Robert Fusco: Allstate Insurance
Robert Fusco: Allstate Insurance is a well-known full-service insurance agency. the company offers home insurance, auto insurance, life insurance, and more. You can reach The General’s customer service phone number here: +1 330-793-6262.
4. Ashton Insurance, Inc.
Since 1968, Ashton Agency has been building relationships with businesses across the country by offering simple solutions to surety bonds and specialty insurance needs. We offer a comprehensive selection of surety bonds for all 50 states at affordable rates.
5. Stonybrook Insurance
Stonybrook Insurance is one of the best insurance companies in Ohio. In addition, the company also offers home insurance, auto insurance, life insurance, and more. You can reach The General’s customer service phone number here: +1 330-286-3222.
6. Aveuila Agee: Allstate Insurance
Aveuila Agee: Allstate Insurance is one of the best insurance companies in Mahoning, Ohio. Based in Ohio, United States. In addition, the company also offers home insurance, life insurance, and more. You can reach The General’s customer service phone number here: +1 330-223-6011.
7. McCamon-Hunt Insurance Agency Inc.
Since 1996, the McCamon-Hunt Insurance Agency has continued to bring quality insurance and peace of mind to residents and businesses in Mahoning County. Our friendly service, competitive pricing, and experienced staff guarantee that our clients are receiving personal attention and the best insurance available.
8. Associates For Insurance Solutions LLC
Family-owned and operated company, Associates For Insurance Solutions LLC is an independent insurance agency. We do not work for an insurance company. We work for you! We’re on your side when you experience a loss; and we follow through to see that you receive a fair, prompt payment.
9. Western & Southern Life Insurance Company
Western & Southern Financial Group, also commonly referred to as Western & Southern, is a Cincinnati, Ohio-based diversified family of financial services companies with $111.6 billion in assets owned and managed as of December 2021.[2] As of 2022, it held a “AA- Very Strong” rating from Standard & Poor’s, a “A+ Superior” from A.M. Best, a “AA Very Strong” from Fitch, a “Aa3 Excellent” from Moody’s, and a “96 out of 100” Comdex ranking.[1]
10. Mark Cole Agency
Mark Cole Agency is a locally and privately-owned insurance brokerage in Mahoning, Ohio. The company also offers home insurance, life insurance, and more. You can reach The General’s customer service phone number here: +1 330-953-1308.
