Are you looking for the best insurance companies in St. Johns, Florida? Well, there are numerous insurance companies in St. Johns, Florida. However, before you settle for one, you need to shop around and compare quotes from multiple companies.
There are so many factors that insurers use to determine the cost of your insurance. Some of these factors include the type of insurance e.g auto insurance, health insurance, travel insurance, property insurance, etc., and your age, among others. That’s why you need to search for the best and cheapest insurance companies in St. Johns before making a choice.
To aid you in making the right choice, we have compiled the list of the cheapest and best insurance companies in St. Johns.
10 Best Insurance Companies in St. Johns, Florida 2025
Below is the list of the best insurance companies in St. Johns, Florida.
1. Brightway Insurance
Established in 2008, Brightway is one of the largest privately owned property/casualty insurance distribution companies in the U.S. with over 300 franchises in all the counties. You can reach The General’s customer service phone number here: +1 904-823-3699.
2. SafeState Insurance Group
Safetech Insurance Group is one of the best insurance companies in Florida. They are best known for their products which allow immigrants to ensure their health and safety before traveling. They also offer online appointments and on-site services anytime, any day.
3. We Insure – Rhodes Insurance Agency
We Insure – Rhodes Insurance Agency is a reputable insurance company in St. Johns, Florida. Located at Nature Walk Pkwy Suite 104, St. Augustine. They are regarded as the “cheapest full coverage car insurance in FL” due to their cheap insurance services.
4. Family Tree Financial Group
Family Tree Financial Group is an independent financial advisory firm located in northeast Florida, primarily serving the Jacksonville and St. Augustine surrounding areas, but also has clients in many different states.
5. US Patriot Title LLC
US Patriot Title LLC is one of the best insurance companies in Florida. In addition, the company also offers home insurance, auto insurance, life insurance, and more. You can reach The General’s customer service phone number here: +1 904-518-5127.
6. Victory Title of St. Johns County LLC
Victory Title of St. Johns County LLC is a reputable insurance company in Florida. Located at Nature Walk Pkwy #102, St. Augustine, St. Johns. They are regarded as the “cheapest full coverage car insurance in FL” due to their cheap insurance services.
7. Florida Insurance One Agency
8. Deer Insurance Agency
Deer Insurance Agency is a well-known insurance company fondly referred to as ” a broker for all lines of insurance” because it offers services for all manner of insurance and at cheaper rates. You can reach The General’s customer service phone number here: +1 904-770-6060.
9. Durbin Creek Insurance
Durbin Creek Insurance is a leading insurance brokerage that focuses only on the NE Florida region. We are your local source for all kinds of insurance: from Home to Auto to Business. You can reach The General’s customer service phone number here: +1 904-712-3800.
10. Milam Insurance Strategies
“Milam Insurance Strategies is an insurance company that specializes in tailoring comprehensive, cost-effective, and efficient benefit programs for our clients. We take the time to get to know you and the needs of your company and employees
